
Is a teenage girl’s diary documentary evidence, a novel, or a medical record? Consider one riddled with paperclips, strips of paper easily extractable in the event of a subpoena or simply an adult with a demand. The girl labels these fragments “removable truths.” One is entitled “My Greatest Regret.”
Written soon after her mother died and inserted between upbeat entries, the girl records rejecting her mother’s requests to spend time together. Family members called her mother’s death by drowning soon after a hospitalization for depression suicide; decades later, she still insists it was accidental. If that girl grows up to become a psychologist specializing in memory’s fallibility, does her diary become a prophecy, testimony, or juvenilia?
That teenager has grown up. Elizabeth Loftus, at 81, has spent much of her career debunking theories around memory repression in the wake of trauma, providing expert testimony for the defense in legal cases of sexual abuse: she has taken the stand for Michael Jackson, Harvey Weinstein, and Ghislaine Maxwell, among others. Hers is one of six “stories of mothers and daughters,” as the subtitle puts it, collected in the New Yorker writer Rachel Aviv’s second book of nonfiction, You Won’t Get Free of It. The subtitle is accurate, if desperately insufficient—a fact that deftly proves one of the book’s underlying arguments: what you call a story, and who you allow to tell it, alters not just its classification, but its ending, and which of its interred truths rise to the surface.
These are stories of parenting and coming-of-age, but also romantic tragedies, case studies in the failures of our mental healthcare infrastructure, and meditations on the numinous undersides of grief, mental illness, and artistry. Aviv attends to questions of narratorial authority, psychological agency, and relational veracity, approaching people in dire straits on an even keel, listening closely. Her work reveals how our identities evolve through dyadic relationships—not only between mothers and daughters, but also between patients and doctors, caregivers and wards, and journalists and subjects.
In the preface, Aviv quotes Yiyun Li’s contention that “the essence of growing up is to play hide and seek with one’s mother successfully,” and describes her own book’s subjects as “mother-child pairs acting out this game.” The book’s essays are New Yorker stories originally written when Aviv felt “existentially, like a daughter,” which she re-read only to find pocked with evasions when she “returned with a different identification.” Now a mother herself, she decided to revise them, revisiting her earlier subjects, re-interviewing them, and adding details she previously left out.
The project is acrobatic and risky: a dialectical backflip recorded in slow motion, receptive to the contradictions enclosed in any narrative decision. “There are stories that save us and stories that trap us, and in the midst of an illness, it can be very hard to know which is which,” Aviv wrote in her first book, Strangers to Ourselves. Where that book illuminated the limiting determinism of so many mental illness scripts, this one spotlights the liberatory potential of hearing from a larger cast of characters than just doctor and patient, widening the lens and passing the microphone. A bedtime story, a game of telephone, medical records, diaries, love letters–genres alter outcomes. Narrators have blind spots, predicated on where they’re sitting: across from the examination chair, behind the journalist’s tape recorder, in a teenage girl’s bedroom, or at a mother’s kitchen table moonlighting as a desk.
Across her oeuvre, Aviv is a reverent listener. She locates the folds and crevices of personalities, records the foibles of subjecthood stilted by illness or trauma. Days after her book’s publication, Aviv and I met to discuss care, mysticism, Janet Malcolm, and more.

Your title, You Won’t Get Free of It, reads as a potential refraction of your prior book’s title, Strangers to Ourselves. Both books question definitions of selfhood, acknowledging that identity is simultaneously terrifyingly fungible and claustrophobically static, as well as far more dependent on our loved ones’ visions of us than we like to admit. How do you see the relationship between these titles and texts?
I came into the last book thinking I was writing case studies about individuals, and then it became clear that each story was about the whole family. It was very hard to tell stories about individuals with mental illness that felt true if you didn’t take into account the prior generation or next generation and how they were making sense of the illness. You were missing a big part of the harm, and the factors leading to illness or exacerbating it. That idea changed the way I was hoping to write stories, in the sense that there is often a way of focusing on the individual at the expense of the community or the family, and that individual focus doesn’t feel like it’s getting to the heart of the story. I liked the idea of trying to write about relationships as opposed to individuals.
I’m curious what the phrase “case study” means to you. Your profiles of artists could be read as case studies; your case studies can be read as family histories. Your pieces wield a roving, relational lens that refuses to hide the journalist in the room.
Case study is a term that I landed on years ago because I was so admiring of actual psychiatric case studies. I’ve since come to realize that the telling of a life is just an amazing thing to read, never mind the genre. I remember reading John Williams’s Stoner–there is so much drama and tragedy contained in one life. There are so many different moves in terms of transformation, reversal, epiphany, and even the realization that said epiphany was nothing. I really like stories that are closely focused on the interiority of one person, and it doesn’t really matter if it’s related to psychiatric pathology or not.
That transition from revering the case study to considering it one of many genres that might illuminate truth strikes me as running parallel to a shift in the epistemic framework your books interrogate. Your first introduced me to the concept of “epistemic injustice,” harm done to a person whose self-narrative is invalidated. This one taught me about “epistemic humility,” a medical perspective predicated on acknowledging alternative disease models, especially for mental health. How does the fact that different truths can be revealed by the same story, depending on its narrator, influence your writing style?
Who is telling the story: that is a problematic thing. Right now, I’m working on a piece about a scientific study, and the story has been told in beautiful language by the man writing journals as he is committing harms on his research subjects. If I use the beautiful words he used to describe their environment or the things they are doing, am I participating in a kind of aestheticization of their experience, when it shouldn’t be put in those terms? This is a cultural move currently, too; everyone is more self-conscious about who gets to use and choose the actual words. I feel that way, and then I have to reckon with, Here I am telling their story. Am I repeating this thing that happened to them? How many words of theirs can I use to diffuse that tension? Or is it better to acknowledge that tension?
You offer sustained attention to people in pain. You turn that empathetic observation not only towards patients, but also towards well-intentioned, if wayward, doctors like Oliver Sacks, who misrepresented his patients’ stories—a process you describe as potentially an attempt to “lend them some of his narrative energy.”
On the one hand, I think those patients often felt respected or graced by the attention he was giving them. He was so curious about them that he was eliciting a different kind of person. What they were saying was so shaped by his curiosity that at some point, reading his work, you’re thinking, I don’t know if this speaks more to him or to the patient. But it’s an almost impossible line to walk when you’re a writer trying to write about somebody else.
You write, of your youthful relationship to your mother, that there was a “warm, nourishing underbelly to things I may now see as dysfunctional.” That sentence could also apply to the psychiatrist-patient relationships you write about.
The thing I was trying to articulate in the preface, which I never felt I was able to convey, was well put by a friend who read it. She asked whether there is something that is lost in a mother who behaves in certain ways. The very things I was describing as a meltdown in terms of the way that the mother-daughter dynamic was working were also greatly to my benefit. I would say that maybe there is that dynamic in some of the psychiatric case studies where actually the psychiatrist has behaved quite outside of the bounds of the normal. And maybe it was inappropriate.
You’ve used the word “re-attunement” to describe your revisions. Attunement has mechanical and musical resonances–do you see your revisions as invested in shifts to ratios and rhythms as much as informational additions?
It’s about calibrating the emphasis. Being aware of my own personhood, the fact that my own biases, desires, and concerns made their way into the kinds of questions I was asking in the first place, and then wanting not to entirely rebalance it, but just to return with equal opportunity curiosity on the other side.
You describe honing a “restrained, objective” tone in your early career, and finding emotionally confessional personal writing “humiliating,” which made me think about the psychiatric definition of insight as the “correct attitude towards a morbid change in oneself.” Do the stylistic dictates of psychiatric writing inform your personal writing?
I think the psychological is my frame. If I had been trained in a socioeconomic way of understanding the world, I would do that analysis more. With tone, being plain is an ideal for me–not drawing attention to the writing process and the word choice. I want the details to do their own thing. But, and this is something I’ve been thinking about a lot, sometimes I think I go too far in that direction, and people want framing. As a reader, when I read Janet Malcolm, for instance, in In The Freud Archives [a 1984 book about the clashes over Freud’s legacy], she says, “If Freud had continued his own efforts in this direction, he would have become the inventor of a better condom, not the founder of psychoanalysis.” That’s a perfect sentence.
Malcolm’s sentences are utterly unforgettable aesthetically and often existentially, but she sacrificed a certain amount of reportorial authority by revealing her biases in her stylistic choices. You’ve written, of Malcolm, “Perhaps no journalist has ever been so attentive to the emotional dynamics in the encounter between writer and subject, the transferences that obscure our ability to take in the reality of a relationship.”
It’s so interesting–The Journalist and the Murderer [Malcolm’s 1990 book about the convicted murderer Jeffrey MacDonald’s libel lawsuit against true-crime author Joe McGinniss] is an amazing example of her own interests and preoccupations clouding the questions about reality, whether that guy was actually innocent. She was so invested. But the book, which I love, couldn’t exist as it does if she wasn’t invested. What remains is that main insight: it is hard to see the relationship for what it is because a version of transference is existing in each one; your hopes and aspirations and unmet and unfulfilled preoccupations can cloud your ability to sort out the reality of the situation.
Tell me about mysticism in these stories–the word recurs, and one subject’s father says “magical realism” might be a more apt lingua franca through which to recount his daughter’s fugue states than psychiatric writing.
I have always had an ongoing desire to write about the numinous, or to find ways of writing about mystical phenomena in ways I can actually believe. There was a profile I once tried to write about a very mystical person. When I began it, I thought, If I write this profile and I read all his work, I will start to access some element of the mysticism that is important to his work. And it was not happening for me. And I felt that actually, without it happening to me, I didn’t think I should write the piece. With my subject matter, I have to find a way to believe in it to the degree that I have the right kind of interest. I need to be a good reader of it.
I thought of French philosopher Simone Weil a lot while reading this–her mystical intellectualism, her conviction that undiluted attention can be as intellectual a pursuit as argumentation.
I think Simone Weil actually was my bridge into a place where I was like, I can do this. There was a period after reading her where I was trying to get myself to that place. Barbara Bellis [one of my subjects, the mother of Hannah Upp, who has been missing for years] is an incredible person. She was also one of these amazing people who made me experience the power of a spiritual way of looking at the world, and all the ways it held originality–it felt like she was coming up with ways to understand trauma that felt genuinely new to me.
In your profiles of Alice Munro and Joyce Carol Oates, heterosexual romance is almost pleasurably destructive to women’s identities. Munro, after meeting her husband, writes a friend gleefully that “all identity [was] more or less down the drain” after their first date. How do you see those pieces in relation to the “heteropessimism” of recent years?
I’m tempted to think that what you articulated with Oates and Munro is very specific to their generation. For both of those women, writing was a place of strength and durability, whereas they presented to their families as fragile flowers. I don’t know if I can extend my analysis beyond that generation because it felt so painfully specific to that era of transition: being a woman who could be secure in her own individuality, but exclusively expressing that individuality on the page and nowhere else. The most modern-day woman I wrote about in terms of heterosexual love was [philosopher] Agnes Callard. So much of her framing was about sheer strength, exerting intellectual energy over something that fundamentally probably didn’t need to be an intellectual venture, but still not being content to sit with the idea: My emotions feel out of control, and I’m going to leave my husband. Instead, taking that and thinking, I am performing a philosophical act here.
Did you conceive of the reference to Oates’s potential anorexia in your profile as linked to your writing about the disease in medical terms in your first book? The mainstream narrative of anorexia is about control and discipline of the self in narcissistic terms. What gets left out, which your writing pays respectful attention to, is the way that self-shrinking is sometimes an effort to make emotional space for others, rooted in a desire to connect.
I didn’t want to think of it as medical writing because I felt that would be unfair to Oates. I think it is interesting to write about anorexia descriptively in the way that you just described because it’s a mode of moving through the world, and the common narrative about it is so grating, and cringe-inducing, and in ways demeaning. It’s interesting to find people, like Oates, where you can sort of see anorexia, but you don’t even need to use that word. It’s described in such different terms–that’s the Simone Weil connection again, where what was happening could be described as anorexia, but it was operating on this very different plane.
Last year, you asked in a piece, “What has a century of psychological theory taught us, if not to be suspicious of happiness in the wake of trauma? But all those theories now seemed sort of miserly.” That moment was so poignant to me in its resistance to our culture’s obsession with smugness at the expense of multiplicity.
It requires a learned ability to say, Well, I wrote these from one perspective, and now I want to look at them from another. There’s a way of convincing yourself that you told the story the only way it could be told. It has been instructive for me to realize that there are always so many more choices that could be made. Often, when I’m writing, I feel that it’s going best if I’m thinking, This is the only choice I could have made. The times when I’m writing a piece, and I feel like there are infinite choices, that sensation makes me feel like I’m somewhat lost. I want that security, but it was interesting to see that there are all these other people in a story who could burst out of it, and suddenly their interiority could be the center of it.
What was it like to re-initiate contact with interview subjects you hadn’t been in touch with for years? How had the texture of those dynamics changed?
Linda’s sister was happy. Barbara Bellis was in a new mode in her life, where she was finally looking at pictures of her daughter. She had just put up pictures of Hannah in her room, which she had not done before. She was in a new phase of allowing herself to remember. We had some incredible conversations that were partly because of the phase she was in. With many of my subjects, somehow [laughs], they were not too surprised to hear from me.
More of our favorite stories from CULTURED
How Ina Garten, Everyone’s Favorite TV Chef, Learned to Trust Her Appetite
How ‘The Odyssey’ Opening Weekend Birthed Its Own Ticket Resale Black Market
What Do Basketball Stars Talk About in the Locker Room? Fine Art, According to Kevin Love
We Asked 18 Food Insiders Where (and What) to Eat in New York This Summer
Jarrett Earnest on How Lovers Claude Cahun and Marcel Moore Redefined Collaborative Artmaking
Sign up for our newsletter here to get these stories direct to your inbox.






in your life?