The psychoanalyst and CULTURED columnist considers how her relationship to this haven at the tip of Long Island has evolved over two decades.
Shoes and book on a Shelter Island beach
All photography by Bronwen Wickstrom.

On Sept. 7, 2002, a boyfriend brought me to my first wedding as an adultish person.

I was 23. The bride wore Marc Jacobs. The guests possessed that otherworldly category of cool downtown New Yorkers carry best when they wash up en masse somewhere else. They were married on the rolling green behind an old inn on a peninsula surrounded by bays, beaches covered in shells, water dotted by the masts of sailboats, the tide carrying them like soldiers in formation.

One of the hotel’s claims to fame was that Oppenheimer and other scientists met there in 1947 after the atomic bombs that ended World War II were dropped. I had never heard of this place: Shelter Island. A mere two hours from New York, it all felt impossibly far away: marriage, adulthood, the gaggle of cool people, the Ram’s Head Inn itself.

It took me nearly 10 years to find my way back. One friend was improbably hooking up with the owner of the Sunset Beach hotel. (Sunsets on Shelter are genuinely strange. Something about the sheltered winds, the meeting of so much land and water, the way clouds gather there before dissolving.) Another, who always had more money than the rest of us, rented a house across the bay on the North Fork. A third had taken up with a man who lived on the island year-round. I bopped between them, with the awe, the memories, the longing all swirling around as if I hadn’t forced myself to forget that someplace this beautiful existed this close by.

At some point, John Malkovich appeared in a dress and held court at movie producer Andrew Karsch’s house. (Karsch also worked for Ted Kennedy during his presidential campaign and was the brother-in-law of RFK Jr., whom he has since renounced over his alignment with Trump.) I met Jay Bulger there, too, who had just made his documentary Beware of Mr. Baker and was plotting his next film. Arman Naféei always seemed to be DJing for the same group of 20 of us deep into the night; everyone else had to catch the last ferry home at 11 p.m.

Jump cut: I never really left.

Shelter Island nature by photographer Bronwen Wickstrom

I have other names for the island now: Hell-ter Island, Lonely Island, Shit-Talk Island, Incest Island, Racist Island, Hate-Your-Neighbor-as-Yourself-in-Paradise Island. Anywhere lived long enough eventually reveals what is interminably difficult about people, especially people on vacation. “It’s an island!” locals always say, “What do you expect?” Then come the familiar complaints about the Hamptons spilling north, the prices of everything getting higher (a miraculous steak grilled on an open fire at Léon 1909, a restaurant started by Valerie Mnuchin, is more than $90), how that’s terrible except, of course, for one’s property value. Sigh.

There’s Marie Eiffel, the island’s unofficial French ambassador, who runs a market, clothing store, and restaurant, and has caused quite the stir in recent years. (I won’t get into it here, just Google it.) She introduced me to my partner and can therefore be considered partly responsible for the existence of our daughter. There are the summers I now spend with her, just as I spent much of my son’s preadolescence there too.

After camp at Sylvester Manor (a former provisioning plantation sustained by enslaved labor) or afternoons at the Yacht Club’s youth program (the type of establishment that historically refused entry to African Americans and Jews), we escape to Crab Creek. There are never more than 10 people on this stretch between the marsh preserve and the wider Sound. At high tide, water rushes through the inlet so quickly that you can float on the currents like river rapids.

Kids run wild, trapping blue crabs in mud holes, making aquariums full of baby blowfish that look like little pearls when caught. These inlets act as nurseries. I’ve become an expert clammer, digging into primordial mud, testing my resolve against worms, anemone-like creatures, everything crawling over my ankles as I wait for the feel of hard shells on my heels.

Sometimes, when the sun catches fire on the shallow marsh waters and a white egret coyly fishes as my daughter paddles through the pond, I remember that it’s a miracle I somehow found my way back here.

 

More of our favorite stories from CULTURED

Audacious Ghosts and Sunbaked Villas: How to Make the Most of 36 Hours in the Veneto

Is ‘I Want Your Sex’ Actually Gregg Araki’s Tamest Film to Date?

What One Angeleno Learned From a Six-Week Bender With the Downtown NY Art Scene

McNally Jackson’s Sarah McNally Breaks Down the Modern Bestseller

The Best Parks and Pools in New York, According to Luke Evans, Sohla El-Waylly, Bowen Yang, and More

Sign up for our newsletter here to get these stories direct to your inbox.

Keke Palmer

You’ve reached your limit.

Sign up for a digital subscription, starting at as little as $3/week.

Already a Subscriber? Sign in Here

You’ve almost hit your limit.

You’re approaching your limit of complimentary articles. For expanded access, become a digital subscriber for starting at as little as $3/week.

Carey Mulligan

Already a Subscriber? Sign in Here

Carey Mulligan

GET ACCESS. 

Already a Subscriber? Sign in Here

Want more in your life?

For less than the price of a cocktail, you can help independent journalism thrive.

Conner Storrie standing on a street
Already a Subscriber? Sign in Here
Conner Storrie standing on a street

Already a Subscriber? Sign in Here

Want more in your life?

For less than the price of a cocktail, you can help independent journalism thrive.

Conner Storrie standing on a street
Already a Subscriber? Sign in Here
Conner Storrie standing on a street

Already a Subscriber? Sign in Here

You’ve almost hit your limit.

You’re approaching your limit of complimentary articles. For expanded access, become a digital subscriber for starting at as little as $3/week.

You’re approaching your limit of complementary articles. For expanded access, become a digital subscriber for less than $2 a week.
Already a Subscriber? Sign in Here
You’re approaching your limit of complementary articles. For expanded access, become a digital subscriber for less than $2 a week.

Already a Subscriber? Sign in Here

Want more in your life?

For less than the price of a cocktail, you can help independent journalism thrive.

Conner Storrie standing on a street

Already a Subscriber? Sign in Here

Conner Storrie standing on a street

Already a Subscriber? Sign in Here

Want a seat at the table? To continue reading this article, sign up today.

Support independent criticism for $10/month (or just $110/year).

Already a subscriber? Log in.