
Why does music criticism make people so mad?
The battle of wills between artists and their critics is a perennial spectacle (as filmmaker Taika Waititi’s recent Instagram antics remind us), but something about music criticism invokes a distinct form of ire. Stan armies descend. Twitter threads erupt. It’s telling that—even as every notable music outlet from MTV News to Bandcamp Daily to The Village Voice has either shuttered or downsized beyond recognition—the dominant image of a music critic in the popular imagination is a snide white guy in the Pitchfork office, cruelly dismissing your favorite pop diva while extolling the virtues of Animal Collective.
Anthony Fantano is not not that. He’s opinionated. He’s emphatic. And he’s got a bigger platform than virtually any music writer today (apologies to Robert Christgau). His origin story is familiar in the rock fan lineage: early days at a college radio station, working at a Connecticut pizza parlor. But when Fantano started posting front-facing videos of his rapid-fire, stream-of-consciousness album reviews on his YouTube channel, The Needle Drop, 17 years ago, few could have predicted that this was the format of the future. And while other music journalists and content creators have struggled, he’s managed to connect in a way that nearly no other person has. As a professional opinion-haver, he’s prolific, dropping a new video nearly daily and ultimately racking up four million subscribers and over a billion views across his social media channels.
His early videos are a safari of early Millennial indie: Gorillaz’s Plastic Beach, LCD Soundsystem, Crystal Castles, Autechre. But today, the swathe of records he covers is omnivorous. Most importantly, his attitude is earnest. (Fantano has been a vegan teetotaler for years, and it shows.) Reviews of Carly Rae Jepsen and Tinashe live alongside horsegiirL, Lil Uzi Vert, and Swans. His animated delivery, meanwhile, has become the lingua franca of digital-native content. An entire cottage industry of videos responding to his content has cropped up across YouTube, Instagram, and Twitch. Incurring the wrath of stan armies is to be expected, but his unfiltered takes have also ruffled more than a few feathers among musicians, including Halsey, Drake, and Julian Casablancas of the Strokes, who dedicated an entire verse to Fantano in the band’s 2026 diss track “Lonely in the Future.”
This won’t stop Fantano. The next project for the self-proclaimed “internet’s busiest music nerd” (aka “Melon” to his fans, for his buzzed dome) is, what else, a new long-form interview show, A Perfect Interview with Anthony Fantano. With some help from the podcasting studio Talkhouse, Fantano dropped the first episode with Olivia Rodrigo in June. Beginning Nov. 16, the show is set to welcome Denzel Curry and Kenny Beats, JPEGMAFIA, horsegiirL, Chat Pile, and more to a newly constructed studio in Brooklyn. Fans can also expect live performances and a chance for musicians to put Fantano in the hot seat by turning his review system on its head and giving artists the chance to rebut Fantano’s criticisms of their work.
Ahead of the interview show’s second episode, featuring Jane Remover, Fantano caught up with CULTURED to discuss the books that inspired his penchant for music criticism, why negative reviews of albums seem to uniquely rile people, and how exactly he hopes to achieve the elusive “perfect” interview.

Who’s the dream guest, living or dead?
A very funny crossover that we’ve been trying to make happen is Grimes, who has been dodging me for months. She’s been throwing out the idea of us having a debate or doing a therapy session or something on social media, and it’s like, Let’s stop putting weird words on it and just do it. Let’s talk about your AI stuff. Let’s talk about weird clips about you talking about the population falling for some reason. Let’s talk about some of your weird political ties. Let’s talk about the music. Let’s talk about technology and God and whatever’s going into Psyopera.
At some point, I think we want to have Julian Casablancas on to squash the beef. I feel like we need to get on the same page. There’s no reason for this animosity. I think we can smooth things over.
You two need to work it out on the remix.
I think we need to work it out and get back to a place of normalcy.
You’ve had your share of backlash both from artists and stans. What’s the one that you think has stuck to you the most?
The ones that have stuck the hardest, for both reasons good and bad, have got to be the My Beautiful Dark Twisted Fantasy review, the Halsey review, and the Charli Brat review. Whether or not these reviews help me or hurt me is really in the eye of the beholder.
Of course, if I show up to a festival or anywhere that Charli happens to be playing, it’s pretty much a warm welcome from everybody in the area, but then when you go online, if maybe I have a middle-of-the-road or underwhelmed take on a new pop record, there’ll be a snide response: “Oh, you’re just into that cocaine pop.” Or, “You’re just into that rave garbage. Of course you wouldn’t enjoy this.” While of course there are lots of other pop albums that I’ve enjoyed that are far outside the purview of that album, the fact that that review just went as far as it did I think has led a lot of casuals to perceive that as being the only pop record I enjoy. But whether or not these are good things or bad things really depends on who’s mad at me or who’s a fan of whatever record or artist at the time.
Do you take it personally? Or is it just water off the duck’s back at this point, given how long you’ve been doing this for?
It’s been happening for so long, and I feel like I’ve read these takes so often from so many different people that it’s hard to perceive it as personal because it’s all being written at a distance from me. Sometimes people do have a tendency to be very parasocial and very creepy and weird, but that has become less and less the case as the years have gone on, because I’ve just put so little of myself personally out there on the internet.
That’s just by design. There’s a lot that people try to glean about me from some of my politics, or being vegan, or some of the musical preferences that I have, that they’ll try to read into as much as they can. But that’s really all they have to go off of for the most part. All my personal life I just keep off the internet for my own sanity, because there’s nothing for the internet to do with it other than just be weird about it.
We’re here to pull it all back, at least in terms of books, which can be revealing in their own way. Do you have a favorite music book?
One of my go-to books, which I was recommended in college by a professor, is Audio Culture [edited by Christoph Cox and Daniel Warner]. If you are trying to get a grip on music discourse-philosophy, it’s a really good series of reads. Even if you aren’t an avid reader, it’s easy to move through, because it’s a series of short-ish essays, and the points that are being put across are really clear. Having had it in my personal library for over a decade now, it’s always interesting to go back to when the musical and technological paradigms have shifted. There are pieces and essays in there written by everyone from Brian Eno, to electronic and hip hop producers, to very old-school experimental music concrete composers.
There was an awesome piece I was rereading toward the start of the book, long before synthesis in music as we know it was a thing. This classical composer was going over all of these imagined fantastical things that he would be able to do if there were machines in the future with which we could create any sound we wanted. And, despite the fact that he had access to no such technology, everything he was describing was very prescient.
Are you a fan of the Bloomsbury pocket-sized books on albums, the 33 ⅓ series ?
I have a couple. I’ve been meaning to expand my pieces in that series. I have Aphex Twin’s Selected Ambient Works Volume II, and I have Chris Ott’s contribution to the series, Unknown Pleasures. But I don’t have any more.
If you could write one, what album would you write about?
It’s probably stereotypical, but I feel like I’d have to be The Money Store guy. I don’t know how doable it would be, because in my attempts to reach out to Death Grips in the wake of that record, and even in the years since they’ve gone semi-dormant, they’re always playing close to the chest and being very secretive about whatever it is they’re doing or the meaning behind their music. I feel like I can’t be too upset about that because part of their appeal is being as elusive as possible.
I would read that in an instant. Who were some of your formative music critics? Are you a follower of the classic writers or did you not read that at all?
Really not at all. Most of my reading in college was political science stuff. I loved reading a lot of political works. I referenced Howard Zinn’s A People’s History of the United States in the original list that I sent before we had our conversation. I came up reading him and guys like Greg Palast as well. I ate up that stuff as I was pursuing a political science minor in college. A lot of the music discourse that I was into, or was following, was just among me and a lot of my closest friends at our college radio station. Occasionally we would put together these probably poorly written pieces about music that we were into at the time on LiveJournal.
The approach that I try to take with my reviews is just to be as conversational as possible, or at least what would have been conversational for the dawn of YouTube, because a lot of my hot takes and thoughts and opinions were just based on conversations I was having with my friends. It was really just a matter of pointing a camera at those instead.

Who were some of your touchpoints?
I really liked a lot of what Jello Biafra from Dead Kennedys was saying around the 2000s when he was doing his spoken word records. I owned quite a few of those back in the day. Noam Chomsky as well. Other influences on my delivery style and my approach were a lot of the people I saw on YouTube who were having conversations or making content around topics they were passionate about. As much as it pains me to say it, a guy who I took a lot of inspiration from early on was Gary Vaynerchuk, who’s a really weird, almost slightly manosphere-adjacent social media guru these days. That’s his thing now. He’s very much ingrained into that podcast grind culture where you can probably see a lot of clips of him on social media being like, “If you’re not uploading 23 hours a day, then you’re falling behind.” Very nerve-wracking stuff like that.
But if you go way back into his internet history, what originally made him captivating to me, is that he had a very niche, fun wine review show on the internet. It was based off of a wine business that he used to run with his dad. They’d have all this wine coming in, and he would just shoot himself for 20, 30 minutes straight trying all these wines, reading the reviews, giving the notes, talking about how terrible it is, spitting into the bucket and ranting and raving, just high energy all the way. I don’t know anything about wine, but I would pull up every week to watch this show because he was just so compelling and charismatic, and I genuinely felt like I was learning something watching him. I was like, “If this guy can rant about wine for half an hour and people actually like it, why can’t you just talk about music for that length of time?” Music is way more popular than wine.
I think part of the allure, too, is that it is somewhat niche. When I was younger, I had a harder time finding musical community in my town because I couldn’t often go to shows. So you do end up going onto the music-oriented Reddit thread r/mu or NTS or Numero. In some ways the more niche, the better.
I agree. More than any particular music critic or publication, I find interesting personalities that have strong takes and know what they like and have reason behind it very compelling. Even if I’m not super well-versed in what it is they’re talking about, I feel like the way they engage with that thing could be something I borrow from or am inspired by on some level.
What about non-music books? Are you a big fiction guy?
I’m trying to get more into it. To the extent that I was into fiction back in the day, I feel like it was typical Chuck Palahniuk, Kurt Vonnegut, college guy kind of stuff. Recently I’ve tried to get back to reading. Since the start of this year—and this is more than an average for me—I think I’ve plowed through 10 or 12 different books. After mentioning to my partner just how much I’ve been getting back into reading lately, she was like, “Oh, you’re only reading nonfiction.” Then I was at the library casually, and they had a horror section, and I saw Frankenstein. I was like, I’m going to grab this. It took me several weeks to get through it, and then at the very end, I finished it with her right next to me, and I shut the book and said, “See? Men can read.”
Since then, I read this Lior Torenberg book, which is probably the best example I’ve seen of social media turning up in popular media, be it stories or movies or music. Often it can read as cringe and very out of touch, especially if the writer or creator is older. But I thought it was one of the more thoughtful and engaging portrayals of somebody happening upon a social media career in a very short span of time. The book is Just Watch Me, and it spirals out in this self-interested and very awful instance of greed and attention-seeking on their part.
Why do you think people get so pissed off about music criticism? More than other forms of criticism, more than movies, more than art. What is it about music?
I don’t disagree with that assessment, and it’s funny that it persists despite the fact that we’ve reached a place where culturally, movies are very cool right now. It feels like everybody wants to make it known how much they’re into movies and want to see how into movies other people are. I have a somewhat ironic Letterboxd that people have been begging me to actually put a top four into, but I refuse to review or post anything that is not a Christmas rom-com in there. Any Christmas rom-com I write about will be praised to the high heavens and given five stars. So I’d recommend Hot Frosty, if you haven’t seen it.
Adding it now.
Yes. It’s a film about a snowman who turns into a human, and he’s a sexy man. But yeah, despite the fact that movies are really the top dog in a lot of ways now, in terms of artistic discourse, not liking music, or saying the wrong thing about a particular album, really gets in people’s craws more than anything. I feel like it’s maybe the medium that the widest amount of people have the easiest time projecting themselves onto. A lot of people tend to see themselves in their favorite artists or see themselves in their favorite songs. And there’s nothing wrong with that; I’m just as guilty of it as anybody else.
But without a fair amount of thought, and self-analysis, and broadening of your tastes, it’s very easy to take a dislike of that music as personal, because “not liking this song is like not liking me. Not liking this artist is like not liking me. If you attack this song that speaks to my soul because I see myself and I see my life experience in it, that means you’re attacking my life experience.” That’s not true. Your enjoyment of something can’t be entirely based on whether or not you see yourself in it, or whether or not you agree with it.
Have you ever done a video where you go back to an album because your opinion on it has changed so much?
I’ve done several videos and I am planning on doing another where I’ve rounded up a bunch of albums that I changed my opinions on, or I would do a slight variation on the score of something if I could go back, so it’s definitely happened here and there. I was underwhelmed by Kanye’s The Life of Pablo when it first came out. I came to like it more down the road, but that was after he changed the album eight times and then eventually put out a bunch of mixes for the record that didn’t suck ass. There are other records that I had to warm up to by talking to other people and getting their perspectives on it, and taking time away from the album and coming back, like Mac Miller’s Swimming. But recently I’ve wanted to talk about having warmed up to Charli’s True Romance record. I didn’t like it when it came out.
Did you review it back then?
Yeah, I didn’t care for it. But I feel like having enjoyed so many of her other albums since then, I appreciate it more in retrospect now. It helps you see the older work in a different light.
Another example that sort of stuck out to me was Sleigh Bells’ Treats. I really didn’t like that record when it came out: it was just too messy, too noisy, too lo-fi. But going back to those older tracks, they’re bangers, they’re fun. And then another one that I wanted to throw in there was LCD Soundsystem’s This Is Happening. It was probably my most highly rated album of the year when it came out. I think I came short of putting a 10 on it. I probably would put a 10 on it now, so I do regret a little bit not putting a 10 on it, but they also shouldn’t have broken up. I feel like that’s both me and them messing up, so I’m not going to fully put that on me.
Anthony Fantano’s Required Reading
Audio Culture: Readings in Modern Music edited by Christoph Cox and Daniel Warner, 2004
(Amazon, Barnes & Noble)
Aphex Twin’s Selected Ambient Works Volume II by Marc Weidenbaum, 2014
(Amazon, Barnes & Noble)
Joy Division’s Unknown Pleasures by Chris Ott, 2004
(Amazon, Barnes & Noble)
A People’s History of the United States by Howard Zinn, 1980
(Amazon, Barnes & Noble)
Frankenstein by Mary Shelley, 1818
(Amazon, Barnes & Noble)
Just Watch Me by Lior Torenberg, 2025
(Amazon, Barnes & Noble)
Corporate Rock Sucks: The Rise and Fall of SST Records by Jim Ruland, 2022
(Amazon, Barnes & Noble)
More of our favorite stories from CULTURED
What 9 Art-World Tastemakers Would Buy at Auction Next Week, if Money Were No Object
The Nvidia Scandal Is Fit for the Movies. Here Are 12 Just Like It to Watch.
In Her London Debut, Simone Kennedy Doig Pays Homage to the City She Now Calls Home
Reggie Absolom’s Classmates Needed Him to Explain Jokes in His Debut, ‘Club Kid’
Here’s How an Interior Designer Places Artwork in Her Own Home
Sign up for our newsletter here to get these stories direct to your inbox.






in your life?