The anonymous subject of this month’s Are You Hiring? column had his breakout moment when he was a teen. Here, he gets real about ticket sales, his side gigs, and why he's had to learn to project unavailability.
Illustration of an anonymous playwright’s silhouette against a desk with scattered papers, a laptop, headphones, and a coffee mug.
Illustrations by Erin Knutson.

Are You Hiring? is a new monthly column from CULTURED dedicated to the inner workings of a creative career. Each month, an anonymous figure from the worlds of art, media, music, PR, fashion, design, and literature gives us an unvarnished account of how they got in the door, what they wish they knew before they started, and how they actually pay the bills (or don’t).

Everyone (including us) has been talking about the renaissance of American theater. Audiences are growing—and, above all, they’re getting younger.

This is due in part to the upswing in celebrity-led productions: Nothing moves high-priced tickets quite like a famous face. During the 2025–26 season, 90 percent of Broadway plays opened with a film or television star in a leading role.

But theater is also fulfilling a deeper desire, particularly among Gen Z audiences, to divorce the screen. The anonymous subject of this month’s Are You Hiring? column has developed a reliable formula for funneling the extremely online into seats. “We need to give people something they can’t get on YouTube or TikTok, something intellectually or physically grotesque or evocative or dangerous or complex,” he says. Indeed, his 2023 Broadway breakout, which tapped into a growing sense of digital anxiety and isolation, was likened by one critic to “a Black Mirror episode.”

Our anonymous playwright’s latest Off-Broadway production found champions among a certain breed of socially prominent (and digitally native) downtowner, earning it a cult reputation that has paid very literal dividends: recently, his play announced an extended run. Here, he tells us how he pays for plays, what makes him jealous of nepos, and how he and his fiancée split the rent.

are you hiring graphic

How does the theater world feel to you right now?

Appetite for theater is at an all-time high. There’s a fascination with the tactile and experiential—things that can’t live on the phone. At the same time, theater has never been less affordable for audiences, or to produce.

What are you known for?

I guess my little team of friends and I are known for doing things ourselves, being super hands-on. I don’t know if people realize how scrappy we really are. It’d be slightly embarrassing if they did. Maybe the work is known for being provocative? I don’t know. Doesn’t feel like my place or job to say. I try to tune out what people are telling me about the work in the macro sense, which is hard because I love hearing which moments and lines pop for people.

When did you discover that writing plays could be a profession?

I did an off-Broadway play when I was in sixth grade that I got paid $200 a week for. I remember being like, “Damn, I’m sweating my ass off up here, and the playwright is sitting back in the audience making decisions about what I say. That seems like the cooler position to be in.”

Tell us about your first career breakthrough. How did you get your foot in the door?

When I was 17, I had a play at the New York Fringe Festival. Two main things got me in the door: One was having parents who were like, “We’re gonna support you, and we’re taking you seriously.” The other was that it was the very beginning of the Kickstarter era. It was a really novel thing to crowdfund a play. I think I raised over $10,000 on Kickstarter to put on five shows with a four-person cast and a full design team. We were on the site’s homepage—like we were a featured Kickstarter project. Through that play, I got signed at UTA with the same agent I have today.

That foot in the door so young, like all success in the arts, was a confluence of luck and skill. I’ll take some credit for the play, but I also had novelty on my side.

What is the role of provocation or shock value in your work?

There’s a world of difference between “provocation” and “shock value” for me. We need to give people something they can’t get on YouTube or TikTok, something intellectually or physically grotesque or evocative or dangerous or complex. To me, that’s the value of theater in society: to make work unfettered by the constraints imposed by massive corporations. Being shocking for the sake of being shocking is corny and boring to me.

What does a play need to get made today?

A play doesn’t need anything to be made. We should all be staging more in our apartments, in parks, just doing whatever we can to test new work in front of an audience. Too much is made of venue and context. The majority of audiences don’t give a shit about where the play is so long as it’s not too hot or too cold.

For a play to be successful in a more formal setting, it needs inviting, evocative marketing that is narrative-driven. If you’re operating outside of a nonprofit context like me, you don’t have subscribers. So you need to build an audience from the ground up: For better or for worse, you need to give flavors of genre and story via social media. More than anything else, you need great actors. The world is full of them; I promise you can find them. The friend of a friend who has 100k on IG? If they suck, the play will suck. If you cast a “famous person” and they’re bad? The ticket sales you get from their name will dry up eventually. It happens a lot if you’re paying attention.

What do you think is the biggest barrier to entry for your job?

Man, entry is hard. It comes down to the money that you’re born with. I didn’t grow up with parents who could finance my plays, but I did grow up with parents who wouldn’t leave me destitute if playwriting didn’t work out.

What’s something you learned in school and still draw on in your work?

I had a thesis advisor in college who said, “In life there are Beethovens and Mozarts, and we live in a Mozart culture.” Mozart composed symphonies in his head and wrote them down perfectly the first time. Beethoven had to work for every scrap of success that he had. Because I got some success and encouragement when I was so young, I spent some years being a little big for my britches. I was like, “This person should acknowledge that I’m great.” One year, when I didn’t get enough pages done by winter break, that teacher was like, “I think you think you are Mozart, but, like the vast majority of us, you are Beethoven.”

What are people getting wrong about the theater right now?

People in New York don’t realize that as a playwright, regional theaters are your lifeblood. I make some money when my play is Off-Broadway. I make more money by having it done in Philadelphia and Denver and so on. Unfortunately, all of those cities rely on audiences that are old and going to die in the next 20 years, so real structural change is needed if theater is going to survive in America.

Have you ever gone into debt for a project? What’s the most of your own money you’ve ever spent?

Never into debt, but I’ve made short films I paid for myself. $6,000 was the most I ever spent on one of those. In terms of producing theater, I’ve covered costs and gotten paid back a handful of times over the years. I will always assume the risk if the cost is low and it’s something that would make our team’s lives easier. I spent a lot of years working bullshit marketing jobs for that to be the case, so it feels good to be able to reach for the credit card.

What’s one source of stress that you’d never have predicted would come with the job?

Most off-Broadway plays are run through a nonprofit, meaning the worst that can really happen to you is that you get a bad review. But my theater journey is this uncharted path of commercial off-Broadway producing, meaning that my plays have a real possibility of closing early—even if they have some notoriety—if the tickets don’t sell.

Do you get jealous or competitive with your peers?

Crazy enough, given how privileged I am, I’m not a nepo. I do get jealous of the nepos. Like, I pitched that exact same idea, but you’re an actor’s son, so you get to do it. That shit irks me.

What does a typical day look like for you? When do you clock in and out?

I get up when my fiancée gets up for work, around 7:30 a.m. I try to write for a couple of hours in the morning so that, if nothing else happens that day, I’ve already accomplished something. But usually the best work comes between 9 p.m. and 1 a.m.

Do you have a side hustle? How much of your workday is dedicated to that?

Yes. I also work in TV and film. At the moment, I’m rendering services on four different projects. So it’s actually pretty rare these days that I’m putting the pedal to the metal getting pages down. I feel like I haven’t been able to do that for a while.

Do you work on the weekends?

I often write really well after a big social experience. After a night out talking to like 14 random people in a loud house, I love to come home and jam out on some pages. I think that’s the reason they deliberately exhaust the cast on Saturday Night Live. You write dialogue best when your brain is at its most unencumbered.

How does screenwriting compare to playwriting?

Film and TV take a little less out of you. When you’re putting a play into the world and it’s going to Broadway, every single element of the show—even once it tours and you’re not involved with the production—reflects on you. After all that, I find it really liberating to be like, “I’m doing a dialogue pass on this script and it’s not even gonna have my name on it,” or, “I’m the second-from-the-bottom staff writer on this TV show.” I don’t have a screenplay yet that feels like a piece of me.

What have you given up to stay in your job?

Drugs and alcohol.

If your paycheck were a pie chart, where would the biggest portions go?

My rent, for sure. Then probably meals.

Does anyone support you financially?

No, but I come to New York regularly to work, and I always stay in my childhood bedroom.

How do you handle health insurance?

I have Writers’ Guild health insurance.

Do you feel like you’re part of a certain theater community or scene?

Definitely not a community, but maybe a scene. There’s a real scarcity mindset in theater, so I don’t necessarily feel like I’m part of a group that supports each other. But personally, I’ll ride for any actor I’ve ever worked with till the day I die. All of my close collaborators growing up went to LaGuardia High School in New York. There are so many LaGuardia kids I’ve never worked with, but am actively rooting for.

Where does that scene converge?

Around almost any play. Like, I’ll go see one of Adult Film’s shows in Bushwick and inevitably run into people I know. It’s not as sexy as having a bar we all go to, but that shit becomes contrived and anti-creative so fast. Think of what Dimes Square was, the artistic sensibility that was birthed there, compared to whatever it is now.

What’s the most glamorous part of your job? The least glamorous?

The most glamorous part is having a nice lunch with my director and my fiancée—who is also my creative partner and producer—when things are going well.

The least glamorous part is sitting through early previews. You’re watching a full, incomplete version of the play. Then you have to greet the wonderful people who came to support you in your earliest performances immediately afterward, before hosting a production meeting to talk about all the things that are wrong, and then going home and spending four or five hours trying to fix it.

How big a role does appearance play in your workplace?

More than how you dress, it’s important to project this sense of being unavailable. When you’re younger, it’s really important to send thank-you notes. Then you reach an age—no one tells you what it is—where you have to stop. My partner is a TV producer, and she deals with agents who are like, “You can’t meet him. He’s very busy.” Obviously, the most unavailable person is the one everyone wants—I’ve had more success actually being a little bit less gracious. I think that sucks.

Do you have a work uniform?

When I was younger, I emphasized my dirtbag-ish qualities. During college, I’d go out to LA on spring break for meetings, and was very aware of how charming it was to show up to the Fox lot all sweaty with a scruffy beard, an earring, a long shirt, sneakers, and a backpack, then pitch my thing about growing up in the city. Now, I don’t know how to be.

What is your dream job?

“Playwright who actors want to work with.” When my name arrives in some guy from CAA’s inbox, I want him to be like, “Oh shit. Paul Mescal’s gonna be excited about this project.”

How has your attitude toward work changed since starting this job?

Right now, I’m attempting to transition the thing that I love doing most into a thing that can allow me to support a family. That tension is something I really struggle with, and it’s all I talk about in therapy.

What’s one piece of advice you’d give anyone entering your industry?

You’re going to have to work so much harder than you think. It’s unfathomable how much harder you’re going to have to work. The amount you’re going to have to work is infinite. No one can prepare you for it. Just know that.

Are you hiring?

No. Someone needs to hire me.

 

More of our favorite stories from CULTURED

What 9 Art-World Tastemakers Would Buy at Auction Next Week, if Money Were No Object

The Nvidia Scandal Is Fit for the Movies. Here Are 12 Just Like It to Watch.

In Her London Debut, Simone Kennedy Doig Pays Homage to the City She Now Calls Home

Reggie Absolom’s Classmates Needed Him to Explain Jokes in His Debut, ‘Club Kid’

Here’s How an Interior Designer Places Artwork in Her Own Home

Sign up for our newsletter here to get these stories direct to your inbox.

Related Stories

Related Stories

Keke Palmer

You’ve reached your limit.

Sign up for a digital subscription, starting at as little as $3/week.

Already a Subscriber? Sign in Here

You’ve almost hit your limit.

You’re approaching your limit of complimentary articles. For expanded access, become a digital subscriber for starting at as little as $3/week.

Carey Mulligan

Already a Subscriber? Sign in Here

Carey Mulligan

GET ACCESS. 

Already a Subscriber? Sign in Here

Want more in your life?

For less than the price of a cocktail, you can help independent journalism thrive.

Conner Storrie standing on a street
Already a Subscriber? Sign in Here
Conner Storrie standing on a street

Already a Subscriber? Sign in Here

Want more in your life?

For less than the price of a cocktail, you can help independent journalism thrive.

Conner Storrie standing on a street
Already a Subscriber? Sign in Here
Conner Storrie standing on a street

Already a Subscriber? Sign in Here

You’ve almost hit your limit.

You’re approaching your limit of complimentary articles. For expanded access, become a digital subscriber for starting at as little as $3/week.

You’re approaching your limit of complementary articles. For expanded access, become a digital subscriber for less than $2 a week.
Already a Subscriber? Sign in Here
You’re approaching your limit of complementary articles. For expanded access, become a digital subscriber for less than $2 a week.

Already a Subscriber? Sign in Here

Want more in your life?

For less than the price of a cocktail, you can help independent journalism thrive.

Conner Storrie standing on a street

Already a Subscriber? Sign in Here

Conner Storrie standing on a street

Already a Subscriber? Sign in Here

Want a seat at the table? To continue reading this article, sign up today.

Support independent criticism for $10/month (or just $110/year).

Already a subscriber? Log in.